Aquarium enthusiasts love a good looking tank!
Besides the mesmerizing fish and animals, a freshwater fish tank can also be beautified with props and other tank décor.
However, the largest thing that determines the aesthetic appeal of the tank and ensures the health of the animals is the substrate of your tank.
The substrate refers to the material that’s at the bottom of the tank – think of it as the seabed. It plays an important part in the water’s chemistry and also plays a major role in filtration.
Besides that, it also helps to ensure the well being of the aquarium’s animals and also gives aesthetic appeal. In fact, in many tanks, the substrate also provides nutrients and a secure footing to aquarium plants, too!
One common question experts are faced with is whether beach sand can be used as a substrate in freshwater aquarium. Because fish are aquatic creatures, it’s natural for first-time aquarium owners to ask this question.
Turns out, there’s a pretty surprising answer to this question.
Can Beach Sand be used in a Freshwater Aquarium?
Beach sand should NEVER be used in an aquarium, let alone a freshwater aquarium. The beach sand is contaminated by the seawater, which has drastic chemistry and is also filled with many harmful compounds.
Even though it sounds logical to use beach sand for aquatic animals, it’s an extremely harmful thing to use as the substrate.
As a result, experts and aquarium enthusiasts prohibit the use of beach sand in a freshwater aquarium.
Dangers of Using Beach Sand in a Freshwater Aquarium
As surprised as you may be, there are many viable reasons why beach sand is the worst kind of material to use for your freshwater tank’s substrate. With the rising pollution and environmental concerns, seawater and beach sand are some of the most polluted things.
Various oil spills, leaked sewage, chemical waste, human waste and other kinds of contamination are found in the seawater and as a result, it’s transferred onto the sand, making it one of the most harmful kinds of substrates for freshwater aquarium.
Unfortunately, there are more dangers associated with using beach sand for the aquarium substrate.
It Contains Harmful Microorganisms
The beach sand is full of microorganisms that could harm your tank’s ecosystem and also cause harm to your fish.
Different kinds of bacteria, parasites, and strains of infections can be transferred to the tank animals if beach sand is used as a substrate.
The beach sand also contains microbes, which can pass deadly viruses and waterborne pathogens to your tank animals and also compromise the water quality, rendering it unsafe and unhealthy for your fish.
It Contains Pollutants
Beach sand contains harmful pollutants like chemicals, heavy metals and other organic and inorganic compounds that are unsuitable for freshwater tanks.
According to research, these compounds can severely hamper human health, let alone aquatic animals!
It’s not worth the risk to include beach sand in your substrate. The pollutants may react severely with the tank water and produce toxicity. This will, in turn, result in diseases like skin rot, bloating and many other problems, which can ultimately result in death.
It Contains Waste
It’s common knowledge that beach sand is home to litter and contaminants. Large amounts of human waste, medical waste, and industrial waste are released into the ocean, which also affects the beach sand.
The waste particles break down and are too tiny to identify unless you use a microscope. When added to a freshwater tank, they can poison the water and make your tank animals vulnerable to disease and other threatening illnesses.
It Contains Harmful Levels of Sodium and Acidity
Aquariums need a certain pH level to sustain marine life – although this depends on the kind of fish you have, the pH levels are nowhere close to the beach sand.
Tank animals are very sensitive to water changes. Levels of acidity, sodium, nitrates and other important compounds present in the water can be affected by the substrate of your choice, automatically making beach sand a very wrong option.
What Does The Ideal Freshwater Substrate Look Like? Here’s What To Look For!
So what does the perfect substrate look like?
Besides adding aesthetic appeal to your tank, the substrate is very important when it comes to aiding filtration, promoting aquarium plant growth and also ensuring that the freshwater animals are healthy and thriving.
How do you decide what kind of substrate your tank needs?
Type of Fish and Its Size
The type of fish you have is a major deciding point in what kind of substrate you should get. Fish that are bottom dwellers need flat ground, so using round particles like stones or pebbles is a bad idea.
You also want to consider fish size – bigger ones can move around certain particles, which can be hazardous.
Similarly, if your fish is the active and/or aggressive type, maybe using a grassy substrate is a bad idea because they’ll pull out the plants and even tip over gravel and hurt themselves in the process. Look up the traits and characteristics of your fish before picking a substrate.
Size of The Particles
The size of the particles is extremely important. You don’t want super tiny particles that can become a choking hazard for the fish or large particles in which your fish can get stuck. You also want to look for particles that are easy to clean, especially if you’ve got fish that produce a lot of waste.
Besides, large-sized particles also allow fish waste and uneaten food to pass through to the bottom of the tank, which can make cleanup a very tough job and can also release harmful gases in the water.
On the other hand, particles that are too small can be sucked up by the substrate vacuum. In other words, it’s essential you look for adequately sized particles.
Reactivity With the Water
The substrate does react with the fresh water tank water’s pH levels, contrary to popular belief, which means you have to consider the preference of your aquarium animals when getting a substrate.
Some fish prefer lower pH levels, like African Chichlids, whereas some require a higher level. Your substrate should be able to buffer the water and have a healthy effect on the tank water quality and animals.
Impact on the Aquarium Animals
Fish are very interesting creatures and have certain characteristics. One such characteristic is their reaction to colors. According to research, certain fish shy away from brightly colored substrates and will dull their color.
It’s also important to choose a substrate that won’t harm your fish; for example, you should eschew jagged rocks or pointy pebbles to avoid your tank animals from running into accidents, which can result in broken fins and wounds.
Though not many fish are phased by color, picking a substrate that serves its purpose and has a great color is possible.
Dark substrate can make light and bright colored fish stand out, while lighter colored substrate particles can make darker fish and animals stand out. Either way, the color should be the last criteria for choosing the right substrate material for your freshwater tank.
What Can Be Used For Substrate Instead of Beach Sand?
Now that you’re aware of the dangers of using beach sand and how to gauge what kind of material works best for your tank’s substrate, here are some cool options to choose form.
One of the most common substrate particles is gravel. Simple, hassle-free and easy to find, gravel gives your tank a natural appearance and is also available in various colors to beautify your freshwater aquarium.
However, the drawback to using gravel is that it can become hard to clean, especially when food particles add waste trickle through it to the tank’s bottom.
It’s also a bad idea to use gravel in tanks where the fish doesn’t like rough substrates, like catfish and snails.
Pebbles are gravel’s smoother relative – they’re relatively safe to use in tanks with most freshwater fish and don’t pose any harm. They’re also available in various sizes and particles and are also easy on the pocket.
However, gravel does come with its problems; fish that are too big can choke on them and the space between pebbles can trap waste, which, if left unclean, can produce harmful gases in the water.
Crushed coral raises the pH levels of freshwater tanks, making it a great option for fish that do thrive in such environments. It’s also a great alternative to sand when you can’t find any and is a safe option.
However, cleaning crushed coral can be a pain – the particles can be vacuumed up by the substrate vacuum but compared to other options, it’s a pretty low maintenance idea for the substrate.
Many aquarium shops sell sand that’s meant for the aquarium. It’s different than beach sand because of the finer particles and hygiene factor. It is also great for filtration – for example, the large waste particles will sit on top, making it easy to clean up.
However, the fine particles can pose a problem when it comes to clean up, but it’s the closest thing to a natural substrate.
Aqua soil is available at various pet stores and is made from regular soil that is baked and granular. It’s one of the easiest substrates to maintain and the nutrients in it are good for plants and can sustain certain fish species.
However, if you do not have plants in your freshwater aquarium, maybe pick another material for the substrate. With plants to use the nutrients, the tank water can become too mineral-rich for the aquarium animals.
Some aquarium enthusiasts also like to use grown moss and other kinds of creeper plants for the substrate. Not only do they thrive well with freshwater fish, but they also contribute to the ecosystem.
However, growing plants like moss take some time as does cycling the water with them. Some fish may also adapt to them or may dislike them and try to de-root them, so do some research before choosing a green substrate!
Some fish types, like goldfish or betta fish, do farewell with or without a substrate. The bare bottom tank is obviously easier to clean and also has a unique aesthetic appeal.
However, this is an unwise choice if you have fish who are habitual diggers and do hide in the substrate – so as a last option, you may keep your substrate bare until you find a material worth using.
Before You Go…
As always, speak to your local fish store professional and get the best advice on the kind of substrate your freshwater fish needs. It’s also a good idea to do some research on water quality, acidity/alkalinity, and nutrients that can sustain your freshwater animals.
Regular clean up of the substrate is also essential to keep your tank water’s quality optimal. Fish waste and leftover food can release harmful gases that can deteriorate the water cycle’s efficacy.
Don’t forget to take this guide with you when you’re picking a substrate – and as a reminder: do not use beach sand!
You may also like the following articles about aquariums: